Site icon Mailtrap

What Is The Best Email Marketing Software for Startups? I Tested & Compared 7 Platforms to Find Out

Choosing the right email marketing platform can significantly impact your startup’s growth. With countless options claiming to offer everything, it’s easy to get lost in the noise.

I’ve analyzed 7 of the top email marketing software for startups to help you make an informed decision. 

This guide breaks down each tool’s strengths and the factors that matter most when choosing the best option for your business. 

So, let’s get into it.

P.S. All written is relevant to the time of publishing

Best email marketing software for startups: a snapshot

PlatformFree plan limits (emails/mo)Pricing*(in US $)Email deliverability focusEmail testing
Mailtrap1,000 15★★★★★Yes
HubSpot2,000 32.5★★★★☆No
Mailchimp1,00056.53★★★★☆No
MailerLite12,00025★★★☆☆No
Brevo900029★★★☆☆No
Moosend30-day trial15.20★★★☆☆No
Benchmark Email30-day trial30★★★☆☆No

*I’ve calculated the prices based on sending 10,000 emails per month to a contact list of 2,000 addresses. These prices are current as of November 2024.

Startups’ email marketing software comparison criteria

To find the best email marketing software for startups, I evaluated key factors like functionality, pricing, and user experience. I also tested each platform’s marketing tools and email tracking features to ensure they fit the demands of a startup’s email marketing strategy.

Here are the features I compared:

Email infrastructure

I checked each platform’s deliverability, reliability, and scalability features to ensure they met startups’ specific needs.

Deliverability: Ensuring high deliverability is crucial for keeping your emails out of spam folders. I picked platforms that prioritize deliverability by offering features like:

Reliability: A reliable platform ensures your emails are sent without disruption, even during peak times. I focused on platforms with high uptime and minimal outages, supported by features like:

Scalability: As your startup expands, so does the need for a scalable email infrastructure. Platforms that adapt to your needs provide affordable ways to increase email-sending capacity as you grow. I only picked providers with the ability to:

Pricing

Startups must manage costs closely, so I carefully evaluated each platform’s pricing structure. I compared free plans, the features available at each tier, and any limitations you might face when using a platform. 

As your startup expands, costs can increase with more subscribers or advanced features. I also looked at how features are unlocked at different pricing levels to highlight any potential extra charges for essential tools.

Note: Pricing structures vary across providers. To avoid unexpected charges, pay close attention to areas like email volume and the cost of additional features. Look for services that have clear pricing, flexible plans, and straightforward feature upgrades.

Marketing email sending

I settled only for platforms that make email creation and marketing automation easy for startups. Automation workflows let you set up recurring campaigns without the need to send them manually. 

Another critical aspect is email list segmentation which allows you to categorize subscribers based on their demographics, behaviors, and engagement levels.  This, combined with dynamic content, ensures you’re delivering the right message to the right audience.

For example, this email would only be effective if your target audience lives in places where autumn is traditionally cold. 

An intuitive email builder is also necessary, especially if you’re a beginner and don’t have design experience. Drag-and-drop functionality makes it easy to design emails from scratch, while the HTML editor allows you to import any pre-existing designs. 

Managing your email list is also important — keeping it clean and up-to-date through features that remove inactive subscribers, bounces, or those who have opted out.

Another key feature I evaluated is A/B testing, which helps you fine-tune your emails to get better campaign performance. Testing different versions of your emails helps you optimize for what works best. This can include experimenting with content, design, or timing. 

Note: Many of these advanced tools may only be available on higher-tier subscriptions.

Email design

Your email design is often the first thing your audience notices, so I tested each platform’s email builder to see how easily it is to create visually appealing campaigns without design experience. A good builder should be intuitive, versatile, and allow for customization through drag-and-drop functionality, pre-designed templates, and the ability to edit HTML for advanced users. 

For example, here’s the email design I created in Mailtrap in just a few minutes. I know it’s not perfect, but I’m proud to say I did it myself!

I also assessed the variety and quality of templates available to ensure that you can choose from modern, mobile-responsive designs that fit your brand. Beyond templates, the email editor should offer high flexibility. This will allow you to make adjustments or create custom emails from scratch. 

Email automation and integrations

I also evaluated each platform’s ability to set up workflows for tasks like welcome emails, drip campaigns, and abandoned cart reminders. It’s also important to know if your mass email provider lets you handle email blasts automatically, with minimal manual work.

Abandoned shopping cart reminder from Sephora

A strong automation feature saves time and ensures consistent communication with your audience. 

In addition to automation, I checked for integrations with other tools startups might use, such as CRM systems and eCommerce platforms. These integrations allow seamless customer data sharing and help streamline your marketing efforts across multiple channels. 

User experience

I placed a strong emphasis on ease of use, especially for startups that don’t have the time or resources to train extensively on new software. I checked how intuitive the interface is, whether it’s easy to navigate, and how quickly you can get your first campaign off the ground. 

Also, I reviewed the quality of onboarding support each platform provides: an individual demo of the product, step-by-step text or video tutorials, live chat, or in-depth knowledge bases.

Customer experience

Lastly, I was very curious to see what real users had to say about each platform. After all, most B2B buyers agree that reviews from real users are one of the most trustworthy sources when evaluating software.

I reviewed testimonials and ratings from other startups and small businesses. I especially paid attention to users’ comments on platforms like Reddit and Quora. 

For example, Mailtrap Marketing Hub has received many positive reviews on Reddit from users who appreciate its features and ease of use.

Also, I reviewed ratings from trusted sources like G2 and Capterra to get a more comprehensive view of how these platforms perform in practice.

Platforms with consistently high customer satisfaction, responsive support teams, and positive user experiences in real-world situations received better scores. Plus, testimonials from similar businesses can be a smart way to gauge how the platform performs under the pressures of startup life.

Best email marketing provider for startups: Mailtrap Email Delivery Platform

G2: 4.8 Capterra: 4.8

Mailtrap is an all-in-one email delivery platform designed to send high-quality email campaigns via infrastructure optimized for deliverability.

The platform is ideal for dev and marketing teams that need a reliable solution for transactional and marketing emails including bulk and segmented campaigns. It offers over 25 ready-to-use code snippets for fast integration, a simple interface, and a comprehensive knowledge base for smooth integration.

Mailtrap provides advanced analytics with a dashboard and visual graphs to track key deliverability metrics. Also, there are stats per mailbox provider with detailed insights to help marketers fine-tune their campaigns and maintain a strong sender reputation.

The platform offers an intuitive template builder with drag-and-drop and HTML editors, pre-designed email templates, a clear campaign scheduler, and other automation features.

What sets Mailtrap apart is its emphasis on email delivery. To demonstrate Mailtrap’s commitment to high deliverability, I ran a test using GlockApps, which showed that more than 90% of transactional and marketing emails sent via Mailtrap land directly in the inbox or relevant tabs, with less than 6% being sent to secondary tabs.

GlockApps: Mailtrap Inbox Placement Test

Pricing

Mailtrap’s free plan allows you to send up to 1,000 emails per month, which is ideal for individuals and small startups. For businesses with larger email-sending needs, Mailtrap has very affordable paid tiers that start as low as $15 per month for 10K emails and an unlimited contact list. All the plans you can check here.

Pros

Cons

HubSpot Marketing Hub

G2: 4.4 Capterra: 4.5 

Source: HubSpot Marketing Hub

HubSpot is one of the most popular email marketing software solutions for startups because it offers all essential marketing tools in one platform. 

With HubSpot, startups can support various marketing channels without the need for multiple software tools. Its all-in-one setup includes content management, SEO tools, detailed analytics, and automation features, including follow-up emails, audience segmentation, lead scoring, and workflows to guide potential customers through the sales funnel.

HubSpot also offers a range of plugins and built-in integrations, such as WordPress and Shopify, that simplify setup. The platform’s onboarding resources, including step-by-step guides, templates, and in-app tips, make it user-friendly, even for those with limited technical expertise.

Pricing

HubSpot offers several pricing tiers to accommodate different business needs. Startups can take advantage of the free plan, which includes email marketing, forms, contact management, and basic reporting. 

For those who need more advanced features, HubSpot’s Marketing Hub Starter plan begins at $20 per month and offers additional tools like list segmentation and email automation. 

Pros

Cons

Mailchimp (formerly Mandrill)

G2: 4.4 Capterra: 4.5

Source: Mailchimp 

Mailchimp is a user-friendly platform ideal for small startups, particularly those in eCommerce aiming to build email lists and engage customers with targeted messaging.

Mailchimp offers a bunch of tools to automate email workflows triggered by actions like sign-ups, purchases, or abandoned carts. Also, it allows for delayed campaigns that let you send timely, targeted emails. The platform offers advanced list segmentation and custom sign-up forms to help marketers effectively target specific audiences. Also, users get detailed analytics to track and improve their future campaign performance.

Pricing

MailChimp’s free plan allows you to send up to 10K emails per month to a maximum of 500 contacts. However, emails sent with this plan will display Mailchimp’s branding in the footer.

The paid plans start at $10 per month for the first year (increasing to $20 per month in the second year) and include 6,000 emails with 500 contacts. Mailchimp frequently offers bonuses and discounts, so check their website for the latest prices and deals.

Pros

Cons

MailerLite

G2: 4.6 Capterra: 4.7

Source: MailerLite

MailerLite is an email marketing tool that encourages creativity and brand personalization. It’s perfect for startups and solo entrepreneurs who want to prioritize aesthetic appeal in their campaigns. 

The platform lets users send customized email campaigns, create branded landing pages, and design pop-ups and forms to capture new leads. With a user-friendly drag-and-drop editor and advanced segmentation options, MailerLite makes it easy to build engaging, visually appealing campaigns. And built-in analytics provide insights to help startups refine their strategies over time.

Another great feature is the ability to add interactive features like quizzes, surveys, carousels, and accordions to emails. These clickable elements motivate users to engage, leading to higher email interaction and improved metrics such as click-through rates (CTR).

Pricing

You can use MailerLite for free if you have up to 1K contacts and intend to send fewer than 12K emails monthly. It also includes essential tools like a drag-and-drop email editor, basic email marketing automation, and simple landing pages. 

The paid plan starts at $9 per month for 500 contacts with unlimited emails. MailerLite’s tiers are highly customizable, scaling up to accommodate 500,000 contacts and 6 million emails per month.

Pros

Cons

Brevo (formerly Sendinblue)

G2: 4.5 Capterra: 4.6

Source: Brevo

Brevo is a comprehensive solution for startups that heavily rely on two-way communication. The platform masters omnichannel communication and allows you to reach your audience via email, SMS, WhatsApp, and push notifications. 

Also, Brevo offers users convenient and robust email automation features to create sequences of emails using multiple triggers and user behavior patterns. To create emails, you can use an intuitive drag-and-drop template builder. 

For sales teams, Brevo has a CRM solution that also has a range of workflow automation scenarios one can use to streamline routine processes. It also integrates seamlessly with popular CMSs, e-commerce platforms, and CRMs, ensuring smooth data flow across all customer touchpoints.

Pricing

Brevo offers a free plan with unlimited subscribers and a daily limit of 300 emails. The paid tier starts at $8.08 per month (when billed annually), including 5K emails, no Brevo branding, customer support, and basic analytics. For the latest plans and pricing, visit the official website.

Pros

Cons

Moosend

G2: 4.6 Capterra: 4.6

Source: Moosend

Moosend’s simple design and focus on key mass email marketing features make it a great option for startups with limited budgets. The platform lets you easily create eye-catching emails, set up automated email sequences, and design engaging landing pages.

The platform is known for its email personalization features, such as dynamic content blocks and merge tags. For automation, triggers include actions like website visits, email opens, or purchases. Moosend also offers email segmentation for better targeting, along with analytics and reporting tools to track key metrics like open and click-through rates.

Pricing

Moosend offers a 30-day free trial (not a free plan!) that includes unlimited emails to a 1K email list, 1 automation workflow, 1 landing page, and 1 subscription form. The Pro plan costs $ 5.60/mo for a list of 500 contacts and unlimited emails. Similar to other platforms, Moosend also offers frequent special deals, so check its pricing page to get up-to-date information. 

Pros

Cons

Benchmark Email

G2: 4.3 Capterra: 4.3

Source: Benchmark Email 

Benchmark Email is a practical email marketing tool for startups with limited time and resources. Its clean, intuitive design helps you create email campaigns, set up follow-up automation, and track performance without unnecessary complexity.

The platform’s key features include automated workflows, A/B testing, pre-designed templates, contact list management, autoresponders, and a wide range of integrations with popular apps.

Pricing

Its free plan allows you to send up to 3,500 emails per month to 500 subscribers to help you stay in constant contact with your audience. It includes basic tools but does not offer automation. The paid plan costs $13/mo and includes 7,5K emails, email automation, landing pages, and A/B testing.

Pros

Cons

Wrapping up

Startups thrive on efficiency and precision, and Mailtrap delivers both with its all-in-one approach. Whether you’re testing your email setup or managing large-scale email campaigns, Mailtrap gives you the tools to control and optimize delivery without the usual roadblocks.

Unlike other tools that merely focus on deliverability, Mailtrap offers an infrastructure with high deliverability by default. Features like real-time analytics, spam checks, and authentication support ensure that emails consistently land in inboxes, giving startups a solid foundation for scalable email operations.

But don’t just take my word for it — try it for free and see how it compares to your expectations!

Exit mobile version